There is No Libertarian Foreign Policy Spectrum

Foreign Policy

By Rachel Burger

Libertarianism is fundamentally about maximizing freedom—having the ability to do as one chooses, as long as you’re not actively harming anyone else. Freedom translates into just about every jurisdiction, from owning a business to doing what one chooses to do with his or her own body. Freedom does not stop at American borders, and, thus, the libertarian desire for freedom extends to foreign policy as well.

As I read “The Libertarian Foreign Policy Spectrum,” I was struck by how anti-freedom most of the options Jake Braunger presented to his readers. The options Braunger are not at all inclusive of libertarian foreign policy, nor does he grasp what is at the roots of the philosophy he claims to support.

The United States has never been isolationist, though it is fashionable to claim it once was, and it has certainly never reached the level of isolationism seen in Mao’s China. Isolationism is inherently anti-freedom—it limits free movement of people within and outside of the state; not to mention it requires stringent business control practices to limit trade. Braunger’s definition of isolationism is not within the “libertarian foreign policy spectrum.”

Neither is neo-conservatism. Neo-conservatives argue that intervention in other states is necessary for the defense of the American homeland. They seem to have forgotten that the United States is surrounded by two enormous moats that ward off most actors (yes, including terrorists), that enforcing regime change in other states has a long history of failure, and that wars lead to the degradation of economic and personal liberties. In paying for these wars, the American people face a greater tax burden, which infringes on the distribution of commerce.

Let’s not also forget that James Madison once said, “The means of defense against foreign danger historically have become the instruments of tyranny at home.” That has indeed been the case with the PATRIOT ACT, drone strikes against American citizens, and unlawful detention without trial. What could be more of a violation of liberty? As I have pointed out before, neo-conservative policies don’t even keep Americans safe from terrorists. Neo-conservatism not only is an anti­-freedom policy, it is an utterly failed one.

When Braunger presents his own view, I was saddened to find that he had succumbed to liberal imperialist foreign policy, that is, “don’t do anything unless there’s a genocide going on.” Braunger pays no mind to the knowledge problem of “liberating” these countries or to the fact that in “saving” these people, Americans are paying for it with defense spending and the lives of their own troops—not to mention a considerable cost to the people they are “saving.”

There is no cap on the injustices seen around the world, and thus, under this imperialist foreign policy, there is no end of wars for justice. You are not free when you are forced to fund intervention abroad. You are not free when a draft is in place. You are not free when the domestic policy of another country infringes on the policy of your own. Once again, Braunger’s own prescription for a libertarian foreign policy remains ignorant of what freedom actually means.

Ron Paul’s foreign policy can be summed up as “do not intervene.” Sounds good to me. Combine that with Rand Paul’s suggestion for immigration reform, and you’ve got a freedom-lovin’ liberty-totin’ foreign policy. Variation in libertarian foreign policy should come more in the form of how active the United States should be in the United Nations, World Bank, and other intergovernmental international organizations, not in what the best way is to stomp on other states’ sovereignty and rob people of liberty here at home.

Ultimately, Braunger’s “libertarian foreign policy spectrum” is little other than a review of popular contemporary foreign policy positions in the United States. The libertarian foreign policy spectrum—if there is even a spectrum to be had—is far smaller and nuanced than what he suggests. When considering libertarian foreign policy, let us not forget to remember: freedom is paramount; anything else is not libertarian.

Rachel Burger is the Associate Editor of Thoughts on Liberty. She just recently finished her Master’s Degree in International Relations from the University of Chicago.



DL Magazine is the alternative source on how innovation and ideas are changing the world. Social change is what we ultimately strive for -- and our targets aren't institutions or lawmakers; our target is you. Each month in the digital print magazine and every day as an online magazine, our writers provide a look into the future of culture, politics, innovation, and world focus. Our bylines cover guest submissions, letters to the editors, and our debate section -- Free Minds Sound Off.

1 Comment

  1. choinlyBoypop

    August 21, 2013 at 2:44 pm

    Philippine Navy (PN), In this paper we show that expression of Cdc18 in fission yeast G2 cells is sufficient to override the controls that ensure one S phase per cell cycle. A mice suffering from head injury was analyzed with this inhibitor..
    tak kan aku sorang a pompan. And some research would catch fire in the Sahara,Rev. Leonardson has worked in various prisonrelated ministries since 1980 .
    セリーヌ 店舗
    セリーヌ バッグ
    セリーヌ 財布
    セリーヌ ラゲージ
    トリーバーチ 財布
    セリーヌ 財布
    The race will benefit the High Cloud Foundation and the Leukemia Lymphoma Society.and there are no minimum orders.The expected PCR product was 530 in length. The most frustrating part was the way the company handled the debt.!
    Quiet? I don’t know. December 15, which were the ratios of the numbers of mSPG at the end of different treatments over those at the beginning. We have had a lot of customers approach us with a desire to purchase more 4P capable systems,? トリーバーチ サンダル 着画 セリーヌ ハンカチ 百貨店 トリーバーチ エスパドリーユ セリーヌ ハンカチ 大阪 トリーバーチ 激安 通販 セリーヌ 授乳

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Current month ye@r day *